HS2 Failure

Published on 17th April 2012

An article by Joe Rukin

The national audit office has produced their long-awaited report into HS1, which has highlighted;

• Passenger numbers have fallen far short of original forecasts.

• Project costs exceed the value of journey time saving benefits.

• Construction costs were 18% higher than target costs.

• Passenger numbers were two-thirds of their forecast level.

• The Department for Transport has no value to attribute to the project’s benefits as they have not yet developed a method to evaluate project costs and benefits (despite High Speed 2 being based on similar project benefits).

• These costs and benefits have not been assessed for over a decade, despite promises made to the House of Commons Public Accounts Committee.

In addition to the under estimated cost of contruction, the NAO believe the final cost to the taxpayer will be in excess of £10bn. Their report goes onto say that “In such cases, departments should ensure that demand forecasts are subject to rigorous scrutiny and scepticism. Departments should assess the benefits under a range of different scenarios, perform a sensitivity analysis of key assumptions and a sense check to understand the reality of meeting forecast demand.”

It has been clear from the start that this has not been done with HS2. The HS2 “challenge panels” were criticised by the Transport Select Report last year for being made up of too many people who were already publicly supportive of high speed rail, and the passenger forecasts have already changed twice in the space of two years. As with HS1, the BCR, which represents the supposed benefits to the taxpayer keeps hovering around 1.5, below which Government rules say the project should not proceed. As was the case with HS1, these benefits of HS2 are completely intangible and there is no method yet devised of measuring them.

Margaret Hodge MP, chairman of the House of Commons Public Accounts Committee, said:

“I am yet to be convinced that HS1 will prove to be value for money. Yet again we hear that value for money will depend on uncertain benefits which have not been quantified. We will want the department to do all it can to realise the benefits and turn this sorry story round.”

Stop HS2 Campaign Coordinator Joe Rukin said;

“HS1 shows just what we have always suspect will be the case about HS2, it will be an absolute disaster. Today we have seen absolute hypocrisy from those supporting HS2. For two years they have been citing HS1 as the perfect example of why HS2 will be a success, whilst completely ignoring the facts. Now it has been proven that HS1 has been a disaster for taxpayers, they have done a complete u-turn and are saying comparing the two is ‘disingenuous’ or like ‘comparing apples with pears’. But in some ways they are right, because what the NAO report shows is that the disaster of HS1 will be dwarfed by HS2. Besides there being even more cost and more intangible benefits used to justify that cost involved, HS1 was something new, there were no rail alternatives. With HS1, the DfT failed to see the competition to get across the channel from low-cost airlines, but with HS2 there are other lines people can use, they can drive and most importantly, with the growth of IT over the next 15 years, they might decide there is no need to travel at all.”

Stop HS2 Chair, Penny Gaines said;

"On top of a massive growth in demand for travel which HS2 Ltd are predicted, the business case for the proposed railway relies on a quarter of the passengers only travelling because the railway has been built. This is already in clear conflict with other Department for Transport policies on reducing demand for travel, such as the Anywhere Working initiative.”


For further enquiries call Joe Rukin on 07811 371880 or Penny Gaines 07765 780553.

More details on Stop HS2 can be found at http://stophs2.org/

People can sign the petition against HS2 via the Stop HS2 website; http://stophs2.org/news/378-petition-government-stop-hs2/ or directly at http://epetitions.direct.gov.uk/petitions/353


Have your say...

Please note: you have to be logged into the site before you can leave a comment

Liverpool street station in the UK at rush hour

Help and advice with train travel in the UK

Train travel in the UK should be a pleasure, not a headache. So if you’re taking a train on the UK railway, start your journey here. We’ve lots of hints, tips and advice to help you find your way around, travel smoothly and arrive in style by train.

Read more

eurostars passing at 375mph from the drivers seat in france


Welcome to our #railchat page. Our #railchat discussions take place over on Twitter, with our resident expert Phil Marsh. If you would like to get involved, please do join us, and use the dedicated hashtag #railchat. See our previous discussions below:

Read more

Old steam train in Shanty Town Museum

Locomotives & Engines

Our rail network would be nothing without them. From Stephenson's Rocket to British Rail Class 92 and beyond, explore the facts, information and anecdotes behind the steam, diesel and electric locomotives that built the age of the train.

Read more


Latest Tweets


Edinburgh Castle

Edinburgh to London Kings Cross by Train

Book in advance with redspottedhanky.com and save 85% advanced bookings.

From £21.00

Buy now

Millenium Dome, London

Birmingham New Street to London Euston by Train

Book in advance with redspottedhanky.com and save 92% on advance bookings.

From £6

Buy now

You may also like...



Follow us on Twitter and become part of our rail community!



redspottedhanky.com is the easy way to buy cheap train tickets online.



Control your business fuel costs with a supermarket fuel card – free to apply, no ongoing account charges and no monthly minimum spend.